75+ Simple Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes - Tempting! (2024)

If you are obsessed with ice cream like we are, you’ve dreamed of making it naturally, like the oldened days. Nostalgia ice cream maker is your brand of ice cream maker! Discover our Nostalgia ice cream maker recipes below!

All of our recipes work great with the Nostalgia ice cream maker! Check them out below!

Please note: If you have a 6-quart ice cream maker, you may need to double or triple the ingredients, depending on how many ice cream lovers you are serving.

This ice cream maker makes ice cream from your choice of ingredients, from fresh cream, fresh whole milk, fresh eggs, and all-natural ingredients worldwide. The ice cream made is purely natural to ensure its freshness and purity. Most importantly, this ice cream maker ensures that it delivers unique flavors you can find in ice cream.

For instance, if it is making sherbet ice cream, the ice cream maker only uses fresh ripe fruits. Purity is what attracts most people, and what’s more fun than knowing this maker recipes? Keep reading and find some amazing Nostalgia ice cream maker recipes.

Homemade Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes

If you are obsessed with ice cream, learning how to make it in the comfort of your home will be the best idea. Ice cream is unlike any other drinks or treats that keep you going to the grocery store. It is something you can prepare in the comfort of your home. An ice cream maker from Nostalgia is one important home appliance that can help you make a variety of ice creams with one press. Look at these recipes arranged in the alphabetical order.

Oreo cookies Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes

This ice cream is easy to prepare and gives the most delicious taste. It offers a creamy texture even when the eggs are not used. It is made of whole milk, heavy cream, granulated sugar, vanilla extract, and chopped oreo cookies. Mix milk and sugar in a whisk until all the sugar dissolves. Add the vanilla extract and the heavy cream.

Add this mixture to your ice cream maker and let it churn for about 20 minutes. Put in the chopped Oreos and let it churn until the mixture is creamy and thick. Pour this mixture into a lidded container and put it in the freezer for 2 hours to be ready.

Strawberry Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes

This recipe features a base of vanilla cream with a fresh strawberry at the top. You will need fresh strawberries, sugar, eggs, milk, and heavy cream. You first need to clean the strawberries and chop them 2 hours earlier and then start preparation. Mix the sugar with the strawberries and put them in the fridge for another two hours.

After that, puree the mixture with a blender. Mix the pasteurized eggs with sugar, and add vanilla, milk, and heavy cream. Then add the strawberry mixture. Pour the mixture in your ice cream maker and let it churn until it is ready. Lastly, put it in a container with a lid and place it in the fridge.

Vanilla Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes

This ice cream will make your mouth water even before it is ready. It is the most delicious treat of this ice cream maker. Get eggs, sugar, whole milk, heavy cream, and vanilla extract. First, use the electric mixer to prepare the eggs for about a minute, add the sugar and keep mixing. When the mixture becomes smooth, add milk, vanilla, and cream to the mixer, where you blend until it mixes well.

Then pour this mixture into the cream maker and ice up it as per the machine’s instructions. If you want firm ice cream, put it in a container and into the freezer for 6 hours. This appliance will make your home-making ice cream more fun.

About our Homemade Ice Cream

We offer 1 to ½ quarts recipes, and all of them work well with this kitchen appliance. We provide you with Philadelphia and custard-styled recipes to help make the ice cream of your choice. Philadelphia-style ice cream recipes are do not use egg yolks as part of the ingredients and are lower-calorie ice cream recipes. On the contrary, the custard-style recipes make ice cream out of egg yolks, which provides a creamier, smoother ice cream.

About the Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker

Nostalgia offers different models of ice cream makers that can help you get the ice cream of your choice, whether custard or Philadelphia style. Here are the most common models of ice cream makers from Nostalgia:

6-quart wood bucket electric ice cream maker

Electric wood bucket ice cream maker

Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker, 4 Quarts, Soft Serve Machine with Easy-Carry Handle

Features

• Most of the ice cream makers come with a kit.
• Cleaning the appliance is easy.
• The lids are see-through to allow you to see the inside and for freezer storage.
• The Nostalgia ice cream makers come with an easy-to-carry handle for convenience.

Benefits

One of the obvious benefits of using the ice cream makers from Nostalgia is that you can have the ice cream flavor of your choice since the appliance allows for Philadelphia and custard-style ice cream. Also, the electric motor helps to ease the churning process. Moreover, you get the touch of , well, “nostalgia,” using the appliance made from real wood. The kits also guide you to make any ice cream recipe you want.

Questions about Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes

People would often want to know information about the brand and its products before even buying them. This information guides your decision on whether to buy the Nostalgia ice cream maker or not. Here are some common questions and responses you might find helpful;

How do you make ice cream in a Nostalgia ice cream maker?

Our ice cream recipe page offers the most detailed instructions to help you make any of the three Nostalgia ice cream recipes. These recipes apply to any ice cream maker you may choose to use.

How long should I churn the ice cream in my Nostalgia ice cream maker?

Different makers give different amounts of time in the instructions to churn the ice cream. The good thing is that you have the instructions to follow. A good example is the 4- quart electric ice maker that says in the instructions to churn the ice cream for 30 minutes. All you need to do is check with the instructions and ensure to keep time.

What is the best way to store ice cream made in a Nostalgia ice cream maker?

As an ice cream lover, you must know that ice cream cannot stay good in fluctuating temperatures. This is why it is not advisable to store it in the fridge’s door because of the frequent opening and closing of the door. This activity keeps changing the temperatures at the door and could destroy the ice cream. It is important to store it in the freezer but in the main part.

Enjoy these Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes!

Go to Serving-Ice-Cream.com Ice Cream Recipe Page from Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes

Go toServing-Ice-Cream.com Home Page from Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Recipes