Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms Recipe (2024)

Ratings

4

out of 5

212

user ratings

Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

Sara

I enjoyed this dish, but I think I would have preferred if it were crispy on the outside. After baking for thirty minutes, the mushrooms released a lot of juices so they were sitting in a considerable pool of liquid. I had to transfer the remaining mushrooms to a different dish. If I make this again, I think I would broil the mushrooms for a few minutes after baking with the addition of some buttered bread crumbs.

Steel this can

Enjoyed, but could use some added brightness. Perhaps a hint of lemon?

Tasha

I added sliced persimmon on top. A touch of sweet was good and added nice color.

Debra Busta Moore

I made this dish for Christmas eve dinner. Instead of lentils I used seitan. Also I added a few sautead sh*taki mushrooms on top instead of tomato. It was a huge hit.

lisa

Have made this a few times and it’s been a hit for vegetarians and meat eaters. Substitutions: I’ve used other herbs (oregano) when I didn’t have thyme handy. Also used fresh basil instead of dried. Store was out of raw cashews so used a combo of raw almonds and walnuts. Chopped these a bit before sauté step. Prepared lentils myself from 1/2 c. Of dried lentils and 1 1/2 c. of water. Used 12 oz.

Michael Hastrich

We made ours as portobello sliders and kept the cashews whole. We added basil as a garnish. Black eye peas replaced the lentils. Served for two with a rye Manhattan and a gin and tonic overlooking dusk on a beautiful lake shore. This one is added to the list of repeat choices.

LyndaOnNorthCoast

We made these as the recipe suggested and they were delicious. I did melt some aged mozzarella on top of the tomato, but we thought the flavors were well balanced. We like our portobellos to be pretty close in texture to a pice of meat, so I’m not sure how crispy (as some folks desired) would fit into that description. Hmm, crispy meat?.

SarahE

Made this and added lemon zest to filling and substituted chopped sun dried tomatoes on top in place of fresh tomato slice

Josh

I really enjoyed this recipe. I like how the cashews roasted in the oven and the rice crisped up. I used some fresh tarragon in the mixture instead of basil. Ya gotta have the tomato on top. Will make again!

lisa

Have made this a few times and it’s been a hit for vegetarians and meat eaters. Substitutions: I’ve used other herbs (oregano) when I didn’t have thyme handy. Also used fresh basil instead of dried. Store was out of raw cashews so used a combo of raw almonds and walnuts. Chopped these a bit before sauté step. Prepared lentils myself from 1/2 c. Of dried lentils and 1 1/2 c. of water. Used 12 oz.

Maddie

Thanks -- I couldn't find canned lentils and didn't know how much to substitute with dry. Your tip helped!

Michael Hastrich

We made ours as portobello sliders and kept the cashews whole. We added basil as a garnish. Black eye peas replaced the lentils. Served for two with a rye Manhattan and a gin and tonic overlooking dusk on a beautiful lake shore. This one is added to the list of repeat choices.

Shari Wilds

Make similar often. Use leftover ‘Joe’s Special ‘ mixed with leftover rice, stuff..bake about 20 mins., cheese (whatever your fancy) on top and put back in oven to melt. Mmmmmmmm so good 😊.

Cherie

This was delicious. Made some teaks second time around. Added smoked paprika and a bit of lemon juice as another reviewer suggested. Also put under the broiler for 3 minutes.

Cherie

This was quite good and a hit with my non vegan, non vegetarian family but all agreed it was a little on the bland side. Next time will add some cilantro and perhaps some paprika with the cashews and onions. Will also try broiling for the last few minutes.

How can you get your mushrooms more crispy with this recipe.?

How can the mushrooms be more crispy with this recipe

Debra Busta Moore

I made this dish for Christmas eve dinner. Instead of lentils I used seitan. Also I added a few sautead sh*taki mushrooms on top instead of tomato. It was a huge hit.

Tasha

I added sliced persimmon on top. A touch of sweet was good and added nice color.

Sara

I enjoyed this dish, but I think I would have preferred if it were crispy on the outside. After baking for thirty minutes, the mushrooms released a lot of juices so they were sitting in a considerable pool of liquid. I had to transfer the remaining mushrooms to a different dish. If I make this again, I think I would broil the mushrooms for a few minutes after baking with the addition of some buttered bread crumbs.

CD

Delicious! We've had a lot of beans lately so omitted them and it was still great. Served with a Brussel sprout and kale salad.

Boxsterblues

Great recipe, lots of compliments from my guests.

Steel this can

Enjoyed, but could use some added brightness. Perhaps a hint of lemon?

Private notes are only visible to you.

Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms Recipe (2024)

FAQs

What is the secret about portobello mushrooms? ›

He emphasized the necessity of cooking Portobello mushrooms before consumption due to the presence of hydrazine, a toxic compound also used in rocket fuel, which can be found in Portobello mushrooms. Cooking these mushrooms effectively diminishes the levels of hydrazine, ensuring safer consumption.

Do you remove mushroom gills for stuffed mushrooms? ›

Mushroom gills are totally edible, but in some cases, they make a dish unsightly. Thankfully, removing them is pretty simple. Most recipes that call for mushrooms don't require that you remove the gills on the underside of the caps.

Why are my stuffed mushrooms dry? ›

A tablespoon or so of heavy cream may need to be added if the stuffing seems too dry. (I did not find the need to add cream.) Taste, and carefully season with salt and pepper . (If using seasoned breadcrumbs, additional seasoning may not be necessary.)

What are the negative side effects of portabella mushroom? ›

Digestive Upset: Overconsumption of Portobello mushrooms can lead to digestive discomfort, including bloating, gas, and diarrhea in some individuals. Allergies: Some people may be allergic to mushrooms, including Portobello mushrooms, which could result in allergic reactions like itching, skin rashes, or swelling.

Why can't you eat the gills of a portobello mushroom? ›

When cooked down, the gills release their spores, giving your dish a dark and murky appearance and obscuring other, more vibrant ingredients. This may not seem significant, but we eat with our eyes first—a dull looking dish can prime our palates to expect dulled flavors.

What are the symptoms of portobello mushroom poisoning? ›

Symptoms include severe gastrointestinal upsets such as abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea. If the person who has eaten the mushroom has collapsed, stopped breathing, is having a fit or is suffering an anaphylactic reaction, immediately ring triple zero (000) for an ambulance.

Can you overcook portobello mushrooms? ›

The mushroom stayed pretty much the same. It got a little bit tougher, but just 57%, which compared to the other stuff is not much at all. It was good at the end of the 40 minutes of cooking; you can't overcook it.

What is the difference between portobello and portabella mushrooms? ›

In the matter of portabella versus portobello, both spellings are used. However, the Mushroom Council has adopted the two "a" version to establish some consistency.

Are you supposed to eat the stems of portobello mushrooms? ›

The stems of large portabella, while technically edible, can be woody and fibrous and are usually discarded (or used to flavor stock). Likewise, the dark black gills can be eaten, but they'll turn your food a nasty, murky, scuzzy brown, so it's best to scrape'em out.

What is the black stuff on portobello mushrooms? ›

Yes, the dark gills of portobello mushrooms are edible. However, most chefs remove them as they darken the color of the dish they are using them in. Why remove gills from portobello mushrooms? Most people remove the mushroom gills during the cleaning process because dirt or sand may hide in the gill structure.

Should portobello mushrooms be washed before cooking? ›

Use a damp paper towel to gently wipe any dirt or debris from the portobello. A damp paper towel should easily clean your mushrooms without the loss of flavor that occurs when mushrooms are cleaned in running water.

Can you eat a whole portobello mushroom? ›

According to the Foodies Family, all parts of the Portobello Mushroom are safe to eat, and most recipes do not require the removal of the gills found in the Portobello Mushroom cap.

How do you dry mushrooms for stuffing? ›

The secret to drying mushrooms without a dehydrator isn't exactly much of a secret. You just air dry them. That's right––just put them in an open container with good airflow underneath them (a mesh colander works great for this purpose), and leave them out to dry for about a week.

Can mushrooms be prepared ahead of time? ›

To Make Ahead: Mushrooms can be sauteed ahead of time and stored covered in the fridge for 3-4 day. Reheat in a skillet until warm. To Freeze: Freezing may change the texture of sauteed mushrooms.

What temperature do you cook baked stuffed mushrooms? ›

Fill each mushroom with the stuffing, and place on a baking sheet. Sprinkle grated parmesan cheese over each mushroom. Bake: Bake for 10 to 20 minutes at 375°F (190°C), or until the cheese browns a little and a little water starts to pool at the base of each mushroom.

How do you keep mushrooms from getting watery on pizza? ›

I take fresh mushrooms and cook them down with a little olive oil, garlic and some other ingredients to make them really delicious before they go on the pizza. When you saute the raw mushrooms first, you remove the excess water that can cause the pizza to become soggy.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Arline Emard IV

Last Updated:

Views: 6241

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (72 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arline Emard IV

Birthday: 1996-07-10

Address: 8912 Hintz Shore, West Louie, AZ 69363-0747

Phone: +13454700762376

Job: Administration Technician

Hobby: Paintball, Horseback riding, Cycling, Running, Macrame, Playing musical instruments, Soapmaking

Introduction: My name is Arline Emard IV, I am a cheerful, gorgeous, colorful, joyous, excited, super, inquisitive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.